Ansible Control Node Windows Limitation Explained

Ansible Control Node Windows Limitation Explained | Generated by AI

Home 2025.12

Question: Why can’t Ansible control node run on Windows, and what role does os.set_blocking have in this?

Answer:

Ansible’s control node (the machine from which you run ansible or ansible-playbook) is not supported on Windows for fundamental technical reasons related to Python’s behavior and Unix/POSIX assumptions in Ansible’s core code. The most commonly cited specific blocker is the use of low-level file descriptor functions like os.set_blocking().

Key Reasons Why Windows Is Not Supported

os.set_blocking() is Unix-only
In several places (especially in Ansible’s connection plugins and process handling), Ansible calls:
```
os.set_blocking(fd, False)   # to make a pipe or socket non-blocking
```
This function does not exist on Windows — it is a POSIX-specific method added in Python 3.5+ only on Unix-like systems. On Windows attempting to call it raises AttributeError.
This is used heavily in Ansible’s ansible-connection process and in the persistent connection logic.
Heavy reliance on fork()
Ansible historically used os.fork() extensively (especially before the “strategy” plugins were made fully daemonized). Windows has no native fork(), only the limited subprocess alternatives, which are much slower and behave differently.
POSIX paths, signals, pseudo-terminals (pty), and /dev/
- Many modules expect /bin/sh, /usr/bin/python, etc.
- Code uses os.kill(), signal.SIGTERM, pty.fork(), etc.
- Windows lacks a true pty implementation until very recently (Windows 10+ has the “ConPTY” API, but Ansible doesn’t use it).
Shebang and executable assumptions
Almost all Ansible modules are written with #!/usr/bin/python or #!/bin/bash shebangs that Windows can’t interpret natively.
Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL) is not officially supported either
Even though many people successfully run Ansible inside WSL/WSL2, it is not officially supported or tested by Red Hat/Ansible because of subtle differences in process handling, file-descriptor behavior, and occasional deadlocks.

Current Official Status (as of Ansible 10.x / ansible-core 2.17+ in 2025)

Control node: Linux, macOS, and other Unix-like OSes only
Managed nodes: Windows is fully supported (via WinRM/PowerShell remoting)
There is no plan to make Windows a first-class control node platform because the amount of code that would need rewriting is massive.

Workarounds People Use

Run Ansible inside WSL2 (works for most cases today)
Use a Linux virtual machine or Docker container
Use Ansible Tower/AWX or the Automation Platform, which run on Linux anyway

In short: the direct technical blocker that causes immediate import/crash errors on Windows is os.set_blocking(), but the real reason is much deeper — Ansible was built from the ground up assuming a POSIX environment.

Back

x-ai/grok-4.1-fast

Donate