Analyze Maven POMs | Generated by AI
To address your query, I’ll provide a solution for generating a dependency graph in DOT format by recursively finding all pom.xml
files in a directory and analyzing their dependencies, without assuming a fixed Maven multi-module project structure like the one in the example (project/module1/pom.xml
, etc.). The script will focus on collecting all pom.xml
files first, then analyzing them to determine module dependencies and output the graph.
Solution Overview
Here’s what the script will do:
- Recursively Collect
pom.xml
Files: Traverse the specified root directory to find allpom.xml
files, regardless of their location or structure. - Parse Module Information: Extract
groupId
,artifactId
, and dependencies from eachpom.xml
. - Handle
groupId
Inheritance: If apom.xml
doesn’t specify agroupId
, inherit it from a<parent>
declaration, if present. - Identify Intra-Project Dependencies: Match dependencies to modules within the project based on
groupId
andartifactId
. - Generate DOT Output: Create a directed graph of dependencies between modules.
This approach doesn’t rely on a predefined directory hierarchy or assume that parent pom.xml
files are in parent directories.
Python Script
Below is the Python script tailored to your requirements:
import os
import sys
import xml.etree.ElementTree as ET
# Define the Maven POM namespace
NS = "{http://maven.apache.org/POM/4.0.0}"
# Cache for groupId to avoid redundant parsing
group_id_cache = {}
def get_group_id(pom_path, pom_map):
"""
Extract the groupId from a pom.xml file, considering inheritance from parent.
Args:
pom_path (str): Path to the pom.xml file.
pom_map (dict): Mapping of pom.xml paths to their parsed data.
Returns:
str: The groupId of the module.
"""
if pom_path in group_id_cache:
return group_id_cache[pom_path]
tree = ET.parse(pom_path)
root = tree.getroot()
group_id_elem = root.find(NS + 'groupId')
if group_id_elem is not None:
group_id = group_id_elem.text.strip()
else:
# Check for parent declaration
parent = root.find(NS + 'parent')
if parent is not None:
parent_group_id = parent.find(NS + 'groupId').text.strip()
parent_artifact_id = parent.find(NS + 'artifactId').text.strip()
parent_relative_path = parent.find(NS + 'relativePath')
if parent_relative_path is not None and parent_relative_path.text:
parent_pom_path = os.path.normpath(
os.path.join(os.path.dirname(pom_path), parent_relative_path.text)
)
else:
# Default to parent directory if relativePath is omitted
parent_pom_path = os.path.join(os.path.dirname(pom_path), '..', 'pom.xml')
parent_pom_path = os.path.normpath(parent_pom_path)
if parent_pom_path in pom_map:
group_id = get_group_id(parent_pom_path, pom_map)
else:
raise ValueError(f"Parent POM not found for {pom_path}: {parent_pom_path}")
else:
raise ValueError(f"No groupId or parent specified in {pom_path}")
group_id_cache[pom_path] = group_id
return group_id
def get_artifact_id(pom_path):
"""
Extract the artifactId from a pom.xml file.
Args:
pom_path (str): Path to the pom.xml file.
Returns:
str: The artifactId of the module.
"""
tree = ET.parse(pom_path)
root = tree.getroot()
artifact_id_elem = root.find(NS + 'artifactId')
if artifact_id_elem is None:
raise ValueError(f"pom.xml must specify artifactId: {pom_path}")
return artifact_id_elem.text.strip()
def get_dependencies(pom_path):
"""
Extract the list of dependencies from a pom.xml file.
Args:
pom_path (str): Path to the pom.xml file.
Returns:
list: List of tuples (groupId, artifactId) for each dependency.
"""
tree = ET.parse(pom_path)
root = tree.getroot()
dependencies = []
for dep in root.findall(NS + 'dependencies/' + NS + 'dependency'):
dep_group_id_elem = dep.find(NS + 'groupId')
dep_artifact_id_elem = dep.find(NS + 'artifactId')
if dep_group_id_elem is not None and dep_artifact_id_elem is not None:
dep_group_id = dep_group_id_elem.text.strip()
dep_artifact_id = dep_artifact_id_elem.text.strip()
dependencies.append((dep_group_id, dep_artifact_id))
return dependencies
if __name__ == '__main__':
# Check command-line arguments
if len(sys.argv) != 2:
print("Usage: python script.py <root_directory>")
sys.exit(1)
root_dir = sys.argv[1]
if not os.path.isdir(root_dir):
print(f"Error: {root_dir} is not a directory")
sys.exit(1)
# Step 1: Recursively find all pom.xml files
pom_files = [
os.path.join(root, file)
for root, _, files in os.walk(root_dir)
for file in files if file == 'pom.xml'
]
if not pom_files:
print(f"No pom.xml files found in {root_dir}")
sys.exit(1)
# Step 2: Build a dictionary of all POMs for parent lookups
pom_map = {pom_file: None for pom_file in pom_files}
# Step 3: Extract module information
modules = {} # (groupId, artifactId) -> pom_path
for pom_file in pom_files:
try:
group_id = get_group_id(pom_file, pom_map)
artifact_id = get_artifact_id(pom_file)
modules[(group_id, artifact_id)] = pom_file
except ValueError as e:
print(f"Warning: Skipping {pom_file} due to error: {e}")
continue
# Step 4: Analyze dependencies
dependencies = set()
for pom_file in pom_files:
try:
importer_group_id = get_group_id(pom_file, pom_map)
importer_artifact_id = get_artifact_id(pom_file)
importer_key = (importer_group_id, importer_artifact_id)
deps = get_dependencies(pom_file)
for dep_group_id, dep_artifact_id in deps:
dep_key = (dep_group_id, dep_artifact_id)
if dep_key in modules and dep_key != importer_key:
# Add dependency as (importer, imported) tuple using artifactId for simplicity
dependencies.add((importer_artifact_id, dep_artifact_id))
except ValueError as e:
print(f"Warning: Error processing dependencies in {pom_file}: {e}")
continue
# Step 5: Output in DOT format
print('digraph G {')
for from_module, to_module in sorted(dependencies):
print(f' "{from_module}" -> "{to_module}";')
print('}')
How It Works
1. Command-Line Input
- Takes a single argument:
<root_directory>
, the starting point for the recursive search. - Validates that it’s a directory.
2. Finding pom.xml
Files
- Uses
os.walk
to recursively traverse the directory tree and collect allpom.xml
files into a list.
3. Parsing Module Information
- Group ID (
groupId
):- Extracted from each
pom.xml
. - If not present, looks for a
<parent>
section and resolves thegroupId
from the referenced parent POM using therelativePath
(or defaults to the parent directory if omitted). - Caches results to avoid re-parsing.
- Extracted from each
- Artifact ID (
artifactId
): Must be present in eachpom.xml
. - Dependencies: Extracts
(groupId, artifactId)
pairs from the<dependencies>
section.
4. Dependency Analysis
- Builds a map of
(groupId, artifactId)
topom_path
for all modules. - For each
pom.xml
, checks its dependencies against the module map to find intra-project dependencies. - Excludes self-dependencies (where a module depends on itself).
- Records dependencies as
(importer_artifactId, imported_artifactId)
pairs.
5. DOT Output
- Outputs a directed graph in DOT format, using
artifactId
as node labels for simplicity.
Example Usage
Suppose your directory structure is irregular:
myproject/
├── app/pom.xml (groupId="com.myapp", artifactId="app", depends on "core")
├── libs/core/pom.xml (groupId="com.myapp", artifactId="core")
├── tools/util/pom.xml (groupId="com.myapp", artifactId="util", depends on "core")
Run the script:
python script.py myproject
Output:
digraph G {
"app" -> "core";
"util" -> "core";
}
This shows that both app
and util
depend on core
.
Notes and Limitations
- No Grouping by Directory: Unlike the original script in the thinking trace, this version doesn’t group modules by directory structure since you didn’t request it. It uses
artifactId
directly in the graph. - Parent Resolution: Relies on
relativePath
in the<parent>
section or assumes the parent POM is in the parent directory if omitted. If the parent POM isn’t in the collected set, it raises an error. - Simple Matching: Matches dependencies by
groupId
andartifactId
only, ignoring versions. - No Property Substitution: Doesn’t handle Maven properties like
${project.groupId}
. - Error Handling: Skips problematic
pom.xml
files with a warning instead of failing entirely.
This script meets your requirement to “iterate recursively, get all POMs first, and then analyze” without assuming a fixed file structure. Let me know if you need adjustments!