A Comprehensive Analysis of 'Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind' | Generated by AI
1. Introduction: Charting the Ascent of Homo sapiens
Yuval Noah Harari’s seminal work, “Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind,” presents a sweeping and interdisciplinary examination of the trajectory of human history, drawing upon insights from diverse fields including biology, anthropology, paleontology, and economics 1. The central tenet of the book posits that the remarkable dominance achieved by Homo sapiens is fundamentally rooted in their singular capacity to conceive and collectively embrace “imagined realities”—shared fictions that have facilitated unprecedented levels of cooperation among vast numbers of individuals 1. This unique cognitive ability to believe in abstract concepts, such as gods, nations, money, and human rights, enabled sapiens to forge social structures of greater complexity and flexibility compared to other human species that coexisted on Earth 1. Harari organizes this grand narrative of human history into four pivotal revolutions: the Cognitive Revolution, the Agricultural Revolution, the Unification of Humankind, and the Scientific Revolution 1. The framework presented underscores the profound influence of abstract thought and communal belief as primary drivers shaping the course of human events, suggesting that cultural constructs hold as much significance as biological or environmental factors in understanding our past and present circumstances. Furthermore, the book’s interdisciplinary nature highlights the intricate interconnectedness of various scholarly domains in deciphering the complexities of human history, advocating for a holistic perspective to truly grasp the multifaceted nature of our collective journey.
2. The Cognitive Revolution (c. 70,000 BCE): The Genesis of Shared Illusions
Approximately 70,000 years ago, a pivotal juncture known as the “Cognitive Revolution” occurred, potentially triggered by a genetic mutation, bestowing upon Homo sapiens cognitive capabilities that were without precedent 1. This transformative period marked the dawn of behavioral modernity and the evolution of imaginative thought 1. Homo sapiens developed a sophisticated and adaptable language that allowed for the communication of intricate information, including abstract notions and entities that lack tangible existence 7. This newfound linguistic capacity to discuss things beyond immediate sensory experience, such as myths, legends, and fantasies, proved to be a critical development 8. It enabled sapiens to form powerful connections around shared ideas, stories, or myths, including concepts like deities or monetary systems, fostering trust among individuals who adhered to the same fictional constructs 9. Harari posits that the ability to engage in abstract thought through language facilitated the creation of shared belief systems, which are indispensable for enabling cooperation on a large scale. Unlike communication focused on concrete realities, the capacity to discuss abstract ideas allowed for the development of common understandings and values within sizable groups, thereby strengthening social cohesion that extended beyond direct personal acquaintances.
A cornerstone of Harari’s argument is the concept of “imagined realities,” which he asserts is the fundamental basis for large-scale human cooperation, particularly in groups exceeding around 150 individuals 1. These imagined realities encompass a wide array of abstract concepts, including gods, nations, monetary systems, human rights, legal frameworks, and notions of justice—all of which exist solely within the collective consciousness of human beings 1. As long as a significant portion of the population subscribes to these shared beliefs, the imagined reality wields considerable influence in the world 3. These imagined orders are effective not because they are inherently truthful or equitable, but because they compel people to cooperate towards common goals 9. “Imagined realities” are thus presented as the very foundation upon which human societies are constructed, highlighting the subjective nature of numerous social structures and institutions. The examples of money and nations effectively illustrate this point, as their existence and power are derived from widespread collective agreement rather than any objective material reality, suggesting that human societies are essentially built upon shared narratives.
The advent of these unique cognitive abilities had profound consequences for the planet. Approximately 45,000 years ago, Homo sapiens embarked on a global expansion, migrating to other continents and leading to the eventual extinction of other Homo species, most notably the Neanderthals 5. Furthermore, sapiens played a significant role in the extinction of numerous other megafauna, even before the development of sophisticated tools and agricultural practices 1. Harari’s observation that “tolerance is not a Sapiens trademark” hints at a potential propensity for conflict and competition that contributed to the decline of other species 13. The rapid proliferation and subsequent dominance of Homo sapiens coincided with the decline of other human species and large animal populations, indicating a substantial ecological impact driven by their newly acquired cognitive and communicative abilities. The timeline and the correlation between the arrival of sapiens in new territories and the subsequent extinctions suggest a causal relationship, potentially stemming from competition for limited resources or the superior hunting strategies facilitated by their enhanced cognition and complex communication.
3. The Agricultural Revolution (c. 10,000 BCE): The Faustian Bargain
Around 12,000 years ago, Homo sapiens underwent a transformative shift from a nomadic lifestyle centered on foraging to a more sedentary existence based on agriculture 5. This transition involved the establishment of permanent settlements, the deliberate cultivation of crops, and the domestication of animals 16. While this agricultural revolution undeniably led to an increase in food production and a corresponding surge in human population, Harari provocatively argues that it represented “history’s biggest fraud” and a “luxury trap” for humankind 5. This perspective challenges the conventional narrative of progress, suggesting that while agriculture brought about certain advantages at a societal level, it also imposed significant drawbacks on the well-being of individual humans.
Harari contends that the shift to agriculture resulted in a decline in the quality of life for most individuals. Farmers were compelled to work considerably harder and yet consumed a less diverse and nutritious diet compared to their forager ancestors 1. The concentration of populations in settled agricultural communities also led to the increased prevalence and rapid spread of diseases 14. Furthermore, the reliance on agriculture introduced new anxieties related to crop yields and the uncertainties of the future 16. Skeletal remains from this period provide further evidence, indicating a rise in ailments such as slipped discs, arthritis, and hernias, likely resulting from the physically demanding nature of agricultural labor 14. The increased labor demands and the deterioration in health associated with agriculture suggest a decline in the physical well-being of individuals, despite the greater availability of food at the aggregate level. Comparisons with the healthier and less physically taxing lives observed in contemporary hunter-gatherer societies lend support to Harari’s argument that agriculture imposed substantial physical costs on the majority of people.
The Agricultural Revolution also entailed the domestication of both plants and animals. While humans cultivated species like wheat, rice, and potatoes, Harari posits that these plants, in a sense, also domesticated Homo sapiens by creating a dependence on agricultural practices for sustenance and survival 7. The process of animal domestication, from its inception, involved brutal practices that, according to Harari, have become increasingly cruel over the centuries 15. He particularly emphasizes the deplorable conditions endured by the vast majority of domesticated animals in modern industrial agriculture, labeling it as potentially “the worst crime in history” due to the immense suffering inflicted 1. The concept of mutual domestication offers a novel perspective, challenging the traditional anthropocentric view of the Agricultural Revolution and suggesting a more intricate and reciprocal relationship between humans and the species they cultivated. Considering the evolutionary success of wheat alongside the increased labor and health issues for humans prompts a re-evaluation of who truly benefited most from this pivotal historical shift. Moreover, the ethical ramifications of animal domestication, particularly in the context of modern intensive farming, raise profound moral questions regarding humanity’s treatment of other sentient beings. Harari’s strong condemnation of animal suffering introduces a critical ethical dimension to the historical analysis, implying that what is often perceived as progress has come at a significant ethical cost to other species.
The adoption of a settled agricultural lifestyle and the subsequent accumulation of material possessions led to the development of property laws and the concept of ownership 15. The Agricultural Revolution also fostered the emergence of more complex social hierarchies, characterized by a large population of peasants engaged in agricultural labor and a smaller elite class that held positions of power and control 14. The transition to settled agriculture laid the groundwork for the development of more intricate social organizations and the rise of social inequality, suggesting that these phenomena are not inherent aspects of human nature but rather consequences of this specific historical transformation. The need to manage resources and populations within settled communities likely necessitated the development of hierarchical structures and systems of governance to maintain order and facilitate resource allocation.
Table 1: Contrasting Forager and Farmer Lifestyles (According to “Sapiens”)
Aspect | Foragers | Farmers |
---|---|---|
Diet | Varied, nutritious, based on diverse wild plants and animals | Less varied, often reliant on a few staple crops, potentially leading to nutritional deficiencies |
Working Hours | Potentially less strenuous, with more varied activities | Significantly longer and more physically demanding, focused on repetitive tasks |
Health | Lower risk of infectious diseases due to nomadic lifestyle and smaller groups | Higher risk of infectious diseases due to settled life in crowded conditions and proximity to animals |
Social Structure | Generally more egalitarian, with less pronounced social hierarchies | Tendency towards social hierarchies with elites and a larger working class |
Security | Relied on a variety of food sources, potentially more resilient to localized shortages | Dependence on specific crops, making them vulnerable to famine due to crop failure or disease |
4. The Unification of Humankind (c. 34 CE): The Forging of Global Bonds
Over the vast expanse of millennia, the initially fragmented tapestry of human cultures has undergone a gradual process of convergence into larger and increasingly complex civilizations 5. The historical trajectory of Homo sapiens reveals a growing trend towards heightened political and economic interdependence among diverse societies 1. Indeed, the contemporary era of capitalist globalization can be viewed as effectively culminating in the formation of a single, albeit multifaceted, global empire 1. This historical movement reflects a relentless drive towards unity, with the entire planet progressively moving towards a more integrated and interconnected world culture 8.
A critical catalyst in this process of unification has been the role of money. Money serves as a universally accepted medium that enables cooperation and facilitates transactions even between individuals or groups who may otherwise be strangers or even adversaries 5. It stands as the most widespread and efficient system of mutual trust ever conceived by humankind 7. Essentially, money is anything that people are collectively willing to accept as a standardized representation of the value of other goods and services for the purpose of exchange 7. Its existence is fundamentally rooted in a shared intellectual construct, a collective belief that transcends physical reality 8. As a shared “imagined reality,” money has been instrumental in fostering cooperation and trade on a global scale, effectively bridging cultural and political divides. The acceptance of a symbolic representation of value allows for intricate economic interactions between individuals and groups who may not share common languages, religions, or other cultural beliefs.
Empires have also played a significant, albeit often coercive, role in the unification of humankind. For the past 2,500 years, empires have constituted the most prevalent form of political organization across the globe 5. Throughout history, empires have often sought to disseminate their core ideologies and fundamental values across their territories 21. While the establishment and maintenance of empires have frequently involved violence and oppression, they have also left behind enduring legacies, contributing significantly to the development of art, music, governance structures, and infrastructure 7. It is notable that the vast majority of people living in the 21st century are descendants of populations that were once part of various empires 7. Despite their often negative connotations, empires have historically acted as crucial agents of cultural diffusion and political consolidation, contributing to the gradual homogenization of human societies through the spread of common languages, legal systems, and cultural practices.
Universal religions represent the third major unifying force in human history, alongside money and empires 7. Religion can be defined as a system of shared human norms and values that are founded upon a belief in a superhuman order or entity 7. Unlike localized belief systems, universal religions have the capacity to transcend geographical and cultural boundaries, fostering a sense of shared identity and community among large populations who adhere to the same doctrines and principles 7. Interestingly, the Agricultural Revolution, with its shift towards settled life and the accumulation of resources, was accompanied by a significant transformation in religious beliefs and practices 8. Furthermore, even secular ideologies, such as humanism, can function similarly to traditional religions by establishing binding moral codes and value systems that provide a framework for social cohesion 21. Universal religions have thus provided a powerful mechanism for uniting large numbers of people around shared beliefs and moral frameworks, contributing to the development of global ethics and values that extend beyond local or tribal affiliations.
5. The Scientific Revolution (c. 1543 CE): The Dawn of Admitted Ignorance
Beginning approximately 500 years ago, the Scientific Revolution marked a profound paradigm shift in how Homo sapiens approached the understanding of the universe 1. A defining characteristic of this era was the growing emphasis on empirical observation and a newfound willingness to acknowledge the limits of existing knowledge. The Latin phrase “ignoramus – ‘we do not know’” encapsulates this fundamental shift in mindset, highlighting a focus on acquiring knowledge through observation, experimentation, and mathematical reasoning 7. The pivotal discovery that initiated the Scientific Revolution was the recognition that humanity did not possess the answers to its most fundamental questions about the world 24. This represented a significant departure from pre-modern traditions of knowledge, which often asserted that all essential information about the world was already known and contained within religious or philosophical texts 24. The admission of collective ignorance, rather than the mere accumulation of facts, is thus presented as the unique and transformative aspect of the Scientific Revolution, paving the way for systematic inquiry and the pursuit of new knowledge.
The advancements of the Scientific Revolution were not confined to the realm of pure intellectual inquiry; they became intricately linked with the expansion of European empires and the rise of capitalism 7. Modern scientific endeavors often required substantial financial investment, and the direction of research was frequently influenced by the political, economic, and even religious objectives of those providing the funding 7. Capitalist enterprises and governments, driven by the pursuit of economic growth and increased power, often prioritized scientific projects that promised to enhance production, generate profits, and provide technological advantages 24. Furthermore, the burgeoning belief in the concept of progress fostered a greater trust in future advancements, which in turn fueled the development of credit and spurred economic expansion 7. This intertwined relationship between science, empire, and capitalism proved to be a potent catalyst for unprecedented progress and global transformation over the past five centuries. The pursuit of knowledge became deeply connected with the desire for political dominance and economic expansion, leading to remarkable levels of innovation and technological development that reshaped the world.
The application of scientific methodologies resulted in phenomenal advancements across numerous fields, leading to significant increases in human power, population size, production capabilities, and overall energy consumption 7. The Scientific Revolution has undeniably brought about substantial improvements in material living standards and overall wealth, at least when considered on a global average 14. Many of the challenges that plagued previous generations, such as widespread malnutrition and infectious diseases, are now increasingly being addressed through the application of scientific understanding and technological innovation 5. The transformative impact of scientific advancements is evident in virtually every aspect of modern life, from improvements in healthcare and communication to advancements in transportation and agriculture.
However, Harari offers a nuanced perspective on the notion of progress, questioning whether these remarkable advancements have necessarily translated into a corresponding increase in overall human happiness 1. He suggests that, despite the significant material improvements, people in the modern era may not be substantially happier than their counterparts in previous historical periods 1. Furthermore, he raises concerns about the ethical implications of scientific progress, arguing that science itself is incapable of establishing its own priorities and often becomes aligned with the agendas of existing powers, be they political, economic, or ideological 7. Despite humanity’s mastery over the environment, its dramatic increases in food production, and the construction of vast urban centers, Harari questions whether we have truly succeeded in reducing the overall amount of suffering in the world, particularly when considering the impact on other sentient beings 24. By raising these critical questions, Harari encourages a deeper reflection on the true meaning of progress and the values that should guide humanity’s future development. The immense power unleashed by the Scientific Revolution necessitates careful consideration of the ethical dilemmas that arise from its application and potential long-term consequences.
Table 2: The Four Major Revolutions in “Sapiens”
Revolution | Approximate Time Period | Key Defining Characteristics |
---|---|---|
Cognitive Revolution | c. 70,000 BCE | Emergence of imagination, abstract thought, and complex language; development of “imagined realities” enabling large-scale cooperation. |
Agricultural Revolution | c. 10,000 BCE | Transition from foraging to settled agriculture; population growth but also increased labor, poorer diet, spread of disease, and social hierarchies. |
Unification of Humankind | c. 34 CE | Gradual convergence of cultures and political organizations towards globalization, driven by money, empires, and universal religions. |
Scientific Revolution | c. 1543 CE | Shift towards empirical observation and the admission of ignorance as a catalyst for knowledge; rapid advancements in technology and understanding of the world, intertwined with imperialism and capitalism. |
6. The End of Homo sapiens? The Future of Humankind
In the concluding sections of “Sapiens,” Harari delves into the potential future of humankind, particularly considering the transformative power of modern technology 1. He explores the profound implications of biotechnology, including advancements in genetic engineering and the relentless pursuit of immortality 1. Harari suggests that the ultimate aim of the Scientific Revolution might very well be the conquest of death and the achievement of eternal life, a quest he playfully refers to as the “Gilgamesh project” 24. Humanity is rapidly gaining the ability to not only manipulate the external world but also to fundamentally redesign its own biological makeup 2. This raises the prospect of a future where the current form of Homo sapiens might eventually disappear, evolving or intentionally transforming into beings with capabilities that are currently considered godlike 20. The rapid progress in biotechnology suggests a future where the very definition of what it means to be human could be radically altered.
Harari also considers the burgeoning field of artificial intelligence and its potential impact on the future of Homo sapiens 1. The development of non-organic, intelligent life forms, such as sophisticated computer AI, represents another potential pathway for the future of our species 1. He posits that the convergence of AI and genetic engineering could usher in an era of “godlike technologies” with the power to fundamentally reshape the world and the place of humans within it 28. One potential consequence of the rise of highly capable AI is the creation of a large “useless class” of humans if computers and algorithms become capable of performing most jobs more efficiently 28. The increasing sophistication of artificial intelligence presents both immense opportunities and significant challenges for the future of Homo sapiens, potentially impacting our roles in society, our understanding of intelligence, and even our very existence.
In his concluding reflections, Harari presents a speculative and thought-provoking vision of humanity’s future. He metaphorically describes humans as potentially evolving into deities with the power to create new forms of life 1. He suggests that just as history began with humans inventing gods, it might ultimately conclude with humans themselves becoming gods 20. He urges us to contemplate the profound question of what we ultimately desire to become as a species, given our rapidly expanding technological capabilities 2. Harari posits that the primary focus of the 21st-century economy will shift from the production of traditional goods to the engineering of bodies, brains, and minds 28. These concluding thoughts serve as a powerful reminder of the immense power and responsibility that come with our accelerating technological advancements, prompting us to carefully consider the long-term implications for the future of our species and the planet.
7. Conclusion: Reflections on a Brief History and an Uncertain Future
“Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind” offers a compelling and comprehensive narrative of the human journey, with the central argument revolving around the pivotal role of “imagined realities” in enabling Homo sapiens’ rise to global dominance. The book meticulously examines the four major revolutions that have shaped our history, providing thought-provoking perspectives on each. Harari’s critical assessment of the Agricultural Revolution as a potential detriment to individual well-being and his nuanced exploration of the concept of progress challenge conventional understandings of human development. Furthermore, his concluding thoughts on the transformative potential of biotechnology and artificial intelligence compel readers to confront the profound implications of our technological advancements for the future of our species.
The book’s broad scope and interdisciplinary approach have garnered significant attention and sparked widespread discussion since its publication 1. While it has achieved considerable popular acclaim and influenced public discourse on human history and the challenges of the future 1, it has also faced critical responses and generated debates within academic circles regarding certain interpretations and the level of factual accuracy 1. Nevertheless, “Sapiens” remains a highly significant and thought-provoking work that encourages readers to reconsider established narratives of human history and to reflect deeply on our present circumstances and the uncertain paths that lie ahead 2. Its ability to connect past developments with contemporary concerns and to stimulate critical thinking about the future of Homo sapiens underscores its enduring relevance in an era of rapid technological and societal change 2.
Works cited
-
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind - Wikipedia, accessed March 22, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sapiens:_A_Brief_History_of_Humankind
-
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind: Harari, Yuval Noah: 9780062316110 - Amazon.com, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.amazon.com/Sapiens-Humankind-Yuval-Noah-Harari/dp/0062316117
-
Sapiens, by Yuval Noah Harari - Eric Nehrlich, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.nehrlich.com/blog/2016/06/15/sapiens-by-yuval-noah-harari/
-
Survival Contingencies: A Review of Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind by Yuval Noah Harari: New York, NY: HarperCollins, 2015, (ISBN 9780062316110) 464pp. $22.99, accessed March 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7198686/
-
Book Summary - Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, accessed March 22, 2025, https://readingraphics.com/book-summary-sapiens/
-
Sapiens Study Guide Literature Guide LitCharts, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/sapiens -
Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari — Book Summary Tyler DeVries, accessed March 22, 2025, https://tylerdevries.com/book-summaries/sapiens/ -
Book Summary: Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari - James Clear, accessed March 22, 2025, https://jamesclear.com/book-summaries/sapiens
-
Fiction, Cooperation, and Culture Theme Analysis - Sapiens - LitCharts, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/sapiens/themes/fiction-cooperation-and-culture
-
Are We Living in Imagined Realities? Why Brand Storytelling Is More Powerful Than You Think - Skyword, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.skyword.com/contentstandard/are-we-living-in-imagined-realities-why-brand-storytelling-is-more-powerful-than-you-think/
-
Sapiens, “Imagined Realities,” Meaning and Yuval Noah Harari’s Values - Medium, accessed March 22, 2025, https://medium.com/nosce-te-ipsum-crea-te-ipsum-know-thyself-create/sapiens-imagined-realities-meaning-and-yuval-noah-hararis-values-3637ae438b83
-
A Review of Sapiens: Imagined Realities Leading to Complexity Beyond Our Wildest Imagination by Mitch Morse Medium, accessed March 22, 2025, https://medium.com/@mitchellmorse/a-review-of-sapiens-imagined-realities-leading-to-complexity-beyond-our-wildest-imagination-5ae69294f53e -
Sapiens – a critical review - bethinking.org, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.bethinking.org/human-life/sapiens-review
-
Book Summary: Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari - To Summarise, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.tosummarise.com/detailed-summary-sapiens-a-brief-history-of-humankind-by-yuval-noah-harari/
-
Sapiens, A Brief History of Humankind - Green House Think Tank, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.greenhousethinktank.org/sapiens-a-brief-history-of-humankind-yuval-noah-harari-vintage-2011/
-
Agricultural Revolution Analysis in Sapiens - LitCharts, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/sapiens/terms/agricultural-revolution
-
Sapiens - YUVAL NOAH HARARI, accessed March 22, 2025, https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1685474627/jbhaorg/erkmxv5civrouuudevem/10thGLSapiensExcerpt.pdf
-
www.litcharts.com, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/sapiens/terms/agricultural-revolution#:~:text=He%20thinks%20that%20when%20humans,humanity%E2%80%94it%20made%20it%20worse.
-
“Sapiens” asks ‘How did humans get smart?’ Bill Gates, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.gatesnotes.com/books/history/reader/sapiens_a_brief_history_of_humankind -
‘Sapiens’ by Yuval Noah Harari, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.ynharari.com/book/sapiens-2/
-
Sapiens: A Brief History Of Humankind by Yuval Noah Harari Sandor Dargo’s Blog, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.sandordargo.com/blog/2020/06/17/sapiens-by-harari -
medium.com, accessed March 22, 2025, https://medium.com/@ilhamsetiawanst/sapiens-a-brief-history-of-humankind-chapter-5-the-scientific-revolution-and-the-rise-of-homo-f0daed13471c#:~:text=%F0%9F%92%A1%20Key%20Insights%3A%20The%20fifth,as%20the%20foundation%20of%20knowledge.
-
“Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind” — Chapter 5: The Scientific Revolution and the Rise of Homo sapiens by Ilham Setiawan Medium, accessed March 22, 2025, https://medium.com/@ilhamsetiawanst/sapiens-a-brief-history-of-humankind-chapter-5-the-scientific-revolution-and-the-rise-of-homo-f0daed13471c -
Scientific Revolution Analysis in Sapiens - LitCharts, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.litcharts.com/lit/sapiens/terms/scientific-revolution
-
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, accessed March 22, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7198686/#:~:text=Harari%20proposes%20that%20since%20the,we%20can%20be%20proven%20wrong.
-
The Revolutionary Impact of Ignorance - Andy Bird, accessed March 22, 2025, https://andybird.com/the-revolutionary-impact-of-ignorance/
-
Book Review Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind by Yuval Noah Harari - Medium, accessed March 22, 2025, https://medium.com/@chris_jack_hook/book-review-sapiens-a-brief-history-of-humankind-by-yuval-noah-harari-fe64816e59cc -
‘Homo Deus’ by Yuval Noah Harari, accessed March 22, 2025, https://www.ynharari.com/book/homo-deus/
- Yuval Noah Harari - AI for Good - ITU, accessed March 22, 2025, https://aiforgood.itu.int/speaker/yuval-noah-harari/